|| powered by |
Emotional children's testimonies are judged as more credible31.03.2014 - (idw) University of Gothenburg
A new study from the University of Gothenburg, show that aspiring lawyers assess child complainants as more credible and truthful if they communicate their statement in an emotional manner. Thus, there is a risk that children that behave in a neutral manner may be perceived as less credible in court.
In an experimental legal psychology study, two young actors (one girl and one boy) portrayed victims in a mock-police investigation. They were questioned by the police about how they had been harassed by older schoolmates. The police interviews were videotaped in two versions: In one version the children appeared in a neutral manner but in the other version, the children showed clear signs of distress, as they sobbed and hesitated before answering the police officers questions.
The films were later shown and assessed by law students that were familiar with the Supreme Courts criteria for how to assess the credibility of testimonies.
The results show that the children, despite giving the exact same testimonies, were perceived as more credible and truthful when expressing emotions than when behaving in a more neutral manner. The reason for these differences was that the law students had stereotypical believes that child victims should appear emotional. The law students also felt greater compassion for the emotional children.
This is problematic since many children dont display strong negative emotions when questioned by police, says Sara Landström, researcher in legal psychology at the Department of Psychology. There is a risk that these children will be considered less credible in court.
Since witnesses and technical evidence are often lacking in cases involving child abuse, courts are often forced to rely solely on the victims own testimony It is therefore very important that courts assess the credibility of a testimony based on what children say and not on how they say it, says Sara Landström.
The study is presented in an article titled Children's Testimony and the Emotional Victim Effect, which was published in the British journal Legal and Criminological Psychology in December. The article was written by Sara Landström, Karl Ask, Charlotte Sommar and Rebecca Willén from the Department of Psychology, University of Gothenburg.
For more information, please contact
Sara Landström, PhD, +46 (0)31 786 4291, firstname.lastname@example.org
The study was conducted by the researchers within the Research Unit for Criminal, Legal and Investigative Psychology (CLIP), at the Department of Psychology, the University of Gothenburg. The study was funded by the Swedish Crime Victim Compensation and Support Authority.
HTML-Code zum Verweis auf diese Seite:
<a href="http://www.uni-protokolle.de/nachrichten/id/275532/">Emotional children's testimonies are judged as more credible </a>